|Picture by Tony Mastrangeli, |
DarkJedi on Boardgamegeek.com
- The modular board - fun to put together; fun to reveal different tracks and people as it goes.
- The structural parts - the ramp spaces up the mountain are very neat
- The group storytelling - it really recreates the movie pretty well, with major plot points thrown and enacted by the players
- The pieces - the rings and the scoring racks are cool; the cards are very attractive, and the pawns with full-color pictures and art are really neat
- Choice - There's very little meaningful choice for the players. You can pick a different character to activate each turn, and this tells different parts of the story, but all the parts will happen eventually, and there are way more characters than there need to be. They have different statistics, and they can pick up items along the way, but these hardly ever matter much. If you face a challenge that you have trouble with, you just keep rolling until you win, or you bring around another character with higher statistics.
- No replay value - the game will turn out the same virtually every time you play it. There's an elaborate set of 70+ events, but they happen in mostly the same order, and they don't interact much at all except to move people around the board. None change the overall course of the game, which is destined to follow the movie's story. There can be trivial differences in path or scoring based on die rolls, but the game will vary hardly at all from one play to the next.
- Rules - the rules are very short, and they don't really explain all of how the game works. We figured it out, but there were some events right off the bat that used terms (e.g. ring bearer) that were not defined, and there were other times when we weren't sure how to use various pieces and had to figure it out from cards. We still don't know how to resolve Nazgul attacks.
- Scoring - the scoring is a good vs. evil rating that you gain from events on your turn. Most of the good or evil that you earn comes automatically from drawing an event or is randomly generated via die roll. It is very difficult to gain very much evil score. By the end of the game, you will have exceeded the scoring scale in the good direction, and this triggers a crude balancing mechanism - you lose 1-6 points when you come to the end of the track. So, the player whose score gets reset last, or who rolls highest when losing points, will lose the game pretty much every time. This is all essentially random, and takes an hour or more of play to get to.